Does the type of microwave change the repair-vs-replace math?
Significantly. A built-in or over-the-range microwave is integrated into cabinetry and often part of a matched appliance suite, so replacement means matching finish, dimensions, and sometimes rewiring ductwork for the vent — that installation complexity alone justifies repairing a $130–$220 issue rather than replacing a $400–$900 built-in unit.
What about countertop microwaves?
This is where the math flips. A new countertop microwave runs $100–$250 in most cases, which is often close to or even less than diagnosing and repairing a failed magnetron or high-voltage diode ($90–$180). For a basic countertop unit, replacement is frequently the more practical call.
What repairs are actually common?
A door switch failure (the microwave won't start, or stops working entirely as a safety measure) is the most frequent call, and it's an affordable fix regardless of microwave type — $70–$130. Turntable motor failures and keypad/control panel issues are the next most common, also relatively inexpensive.
So what's the actual decision rule?
For built-in or over-the-range units: repair almost always wins given the replacement complexity and cost. For countertop units: repair if it's a door switch or turntable issue (cheap fix), but seriously consider replacement if it's the magnetron or a control board failure on a unit more than 5-6 years old.
Call (469) 886-1122 for a straight answer on your specific unit and issue.